UPC proceedings · Challenging a patent

Revocation action before the UPC

Remove an obstructive patent for all UPC states in one set of proceedings – as a stand-alone revocation action before the central division or as a counterclaim in infringement proceedings.

  • Representation before all UPC divisions
  • Attorneys-at-law and patent attorneys
  • Reply usually within 24 hours
EUR 26,500Court fee stand-alone
2 monthsProprietor’s defence
central divisionCompetent
all UPC statesEffect

Two routes to revocation

The UPC provides for the stand-alone revocation action (Art. 32(1)(d) UPCA, R. 42 et seq. RoP) and the counterclaim for revocation in infringement proceedings (Art. 32(1)(e) UPCA, R. 25 et seq. RoP). The stand-alone action is brought before the central division – in Paris, Munich or Milan, depending on the technical field of the patent. If an infringement action between the same parties is already pending before a local division, the attack must be made there as a counterclaim. Conversely, after a stand-alone revocation action, the proprietor may bring its infringement action either before the central division or before a local division.

Grounds for revocation

The grounds follow from Art. 65 UPCA in conjunction with Art. 138 EPC:

  • lack of novelty over the prior art,
  • lack of inventive step – the Court of Appeal examines whether the skilled person, starting from a realistic starting point, would have arrived at the solution; for mixed inventions it follows the EPO’s COMVIK approach,
  • lack of industrial applicability or excluded subject-matter,
  • insufficiency of disclosure,
  • added matter extending beyond the content of the application as filed,
  • extension of the scope of protection after grant,
  • lack of entitlement of the proprietor.

UPC revocation action or EPO opposition?

CriterionEPO oppositionUPC revocation action
Deadline9 months after grantat any time during the patent term
Official feearound EUR 900 (as of 2026)EUR 26,500 fixed
Durationoften 2–4 years incl. appealapprox. 12–14 months first instance
Cost riskeach party bears its own costsreimbursement up to a ceiling
Effectall designated EPC statesUPC states only
Taking of evidencelimitedexperts, witnesses, experiments possible

In many cases both are worthwhile: the inexpensive EPO opposition within the nine-month period and the UPC revocation action where speed is essential or evidence needs to be taken. More on oppositions under EPO opposition and appeal.

Course of a stand-alone revocation action

After the statement for revocation is filed, the proprietor has two months to file its defence (R. 49 RoP). There it can apply to maintain the patent in amended form (R. 50 RoP) and bring a counterclaim for infringement. A reply and rejoinder follow, then the interim procedure and the oral hearing. The central division usually sits with two legally qualified judges and one technically qualified judge. An appeal against a revocation decision always has suspensive effect (Art. 74(2) UPCA).

The counterclaim for revocation in infringement proceedings

The counterclaim is filed together with the statement of defence within three months. The local division then decides whether to hear both proceedings together, refer the counterclaim to the central division or refer the entire dispute there (Art. 33(3) UPCA). The court fee for the counterclaim corresponds to that for the infringement action, but is capped at the fee for a stand-alone revocation action.

Who may bring an action?

Anyone affected by the patent may bring an action – in revocation cases, in practice any natural or legal person (Art. 47(4) UPCA). No particular legal interest is required. Anyone who prefers to stay in the background may in some cases sue through a straw man; this carries risks for later defences, which we discuss with you.

From our practice

Case examples

Typical situations we encounter in our advisory work – anonymised and simplified.

01

Clearing the way for market entry

A heat pump manufacturer plans to enter the French, Italian and Austrian markets. A competitor’s Unitary Patent stands in the way. We bring a stand-alone revocation action before the central division in Munich (mechanical engineering). After 13 months the patent is revoked for lack of inventive step – in time for the heating season.

02

Added matter discovered

When analysing the prosecution file, we find that the proprietor introduced a feature during examination that was not disclosed in this form in the application. We base the counterclaim on added matter. The patent cannot be maintained in an infringed version.

03

Opposition missed, the UPC as a way out

The nine-month opposition period at the EPO has expired when a plastics processor comes across an obstructive patent. A UPC revocation action is possible at any time. We use the opportunity to have an expert heard on the test data that disprove the alleged effect.

04

Combination with an EPO opposition

A medical device manufacturer files an opposition at the EPO in time. When the proprietor sues before the UPC, we additionally file a counterclaim for revocation. The UPC decides faster than the EPO but takes into account the preliminary opinion of the opposition division.

05

A software patent fails the COMVIK test

Against a patent for an algorithm for warehouse logistics, we argue that the claimed contribution is predominantly non-technical. The court applies a standard corresponding to the COMVIK approach and denies inventive step of the technical features.

Your attorneys

Your UPC team: authorised to represent before the Unified Patent Court

Michael Horak, Julia Ziegeler, Stefan Karfusehr, Robin Jannis Mai, Anna Umberg, Katharina Gitmann-Kopilevich, Karoline Behrend and Andreas Friedlein are attorneys-at-law admitted in Germany and are therefore entitled under Art. 48(1) UPCA to represent clients before all divisions of the Unified Patent Court and before the Court of Appeal in Luxembourg. Our patent attorneys contribute the technical expertise.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Can I challenge a patent without having been sued?

Yes. The stand-alone revocation action before the central division requires neither a pending infringement action nor any particular interest.

Does revocation also apply to Spain or the United Kingdom?

No. A UPC judgment only has effect for the UPC Contracting Member States. For other states, national proceedings or the EPO opposition remain.

Can the proprietor amend the patent during the proceedings?

Yes. It can apply to maintain the patent in limited form, including with several auxiliary requests. Later amendments are only possible with the court’s permission.

What does a revocation action cost?

Since 2026 the fixed court fee has been EUR 26,500. Fees for attorneys-at-law, patent attorneys and, where applicable, experts are added. If you succeed, you are reimbursed reasonable costs up to the ceiling.

Read more

Related topics

Act now

Deadlines are running – we review your case at short notice

Statement of defence, appeal, protective letter or opt-out: many steps before the Unified Patent Court are subject to strict deadlines. Tell us about your case – confidentially and under attorney-client privilege.

horak Attorneys-at-law · Patent Attorneys
Head office Hanover: 0511 35 73 56-0
info@upc-anwalt.de
10 offices in Germany · advice also by video call

As of November 2026. This information is provided for general guidance only and does not replace legal advice in an individual case. Legal bases: Agreement on a Unified Patent Court (UPCA), Rules of Procedure of the UPC (RoP), Regulations (EU) No 1257/2012 and 1260/2012, German Patent Act, German Utility Model Act, EPC, PCT.

Scroll to top