UPC · Standards

SEP and FRAND before the UPC

Whether 5G, Wi-Fi, video codecs or IoT: standard-essential patents are increasingly enforced before the UPC. We advise patent holders and implementers on FRAND negotiations and litigation strategy.

  • Representation before all UPC divisions
  • Attorneys-at-law and patent attorneys
  • Reply usually within 24 hours
CJEU Huawei/ZTEGuideline
Mannheim, MunichKey divisions
PMAC mediationAlternative
all UPC statesEffect

What SEP and FRAND mean

A standard-essential patent (SEP) protects a technology that must necessarily be used to implement a standard – such as LTE, 5G, Wi-Fi, HEVC or Qi. Patent holders who have declared their patents essential to standard-setting organisations such as ETSI have undertaken to grant licences on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms. This is not a free pass for users, but it does limit injunctive relief.

The Huawei/ZTE framework

Under the CJEU judgment in Huawei/ZTE (2015), before bringing an action for an injunction the SEP holder must alert the user to the infringement and, if the user shows willingness to take a licence, make a specific FRAND offer. The user must respond promptly, make a counter-offer if appropriate and provide security. Anyone who delays these steps loses the FRAND defence. The UPC applies this framework; in 2024 the Mannheim Local Division issued one of the UPC’s first FRAND decisions, setting out the obligations of both sides in detail.

Tactics for patent holders

  • prepare a notice of infringement with claim charts and reference to the standard,
  • submit a FRAND offer with a comprehensible royalty calculation and comparable licences,
  • choice of division: Mannheim and Munich are regarded as experienced in SEP proceedings,
  • plan the relationship to national proceedings and proceedings outside Europe (e.g. anti-suit injunctions).

Tactics for implementers

  • declare willingness to take a licence early and in writing,
  • submit reasoned counter-offers in time and provide security,
  • challenge the essentiality and validity of the patents,
  • apply for confidentiality orders for comparable licences (R. 262A RoP),
  • offer mediation or arbitration at the PMAC, which is expressly geared to FRAND disputes.

Confidentiality

FRAND proceedings revolve around licence agreements and sales figures. The UPC can restrict access to confidential information to a small group of persons (confidentiality club, R. 262A RoP). The PMAC additionally offers fully confidential proceedings.

From our practice

Case examples

Typical situations we encounter in our advisory work – anonymised and simplified.

01

IoT manufacturer receives notice of infringement

A manufacturer of connected heat meters is notified by a patent pool of LTE-M patents. We immediately declare willingness to take a licence, request claim charts and examine essentiality. After six months, the client concludes a pool licence on significantly better terms than initially demanded.

02

Counter-offer and security

A patent holder sues in Mannheim on a 5G patent. Our client has made a reasoned counter-offer and provides security in the amount of the royalties offered. The court denies injunctive relief while negotiations continue.

03

Patent holder enforces video codec patent

A licensor holds patents on a video codec. A device manufacturer delays negotiations for more than two years. We document this conduct comprehensively and bring an action before the Munich Local Division. The court grants an injunction because the user was not a willing licensee.

04

Mediation on royalty rates

Two companies dispute the royalty for Wi-Fi patents. At the suggestion of the judge-rapporteur, they agree on mediation at the PMAC. With the help of a licence valuation expert, they reach a confidential settlement.

05

Essentiality successfully challenged

A manufacturer of chargers is sued on an allegedly standard-essential patent. We show that the standard provides for an option that does not implement the patent. Because the client uses this option, there is no infringement.

Your attorneys

Your UPC team: authorised to represent before the Unified Patent Court

Michael Horak, Julia Ziegeler, Stefan Karfusehr, Robin Jannis Mai, Anna Umberg, Katharina Gitmann-Kopilevich, Karoline Behrend and Andreas Friedlein are attorneys-at-law admitted in Germany and are therefore entitled under Art. 48(1) UPCA to represent clients before all divisions of the Unified Patent Court and before the Court of Appeal in Luxembourg. Our patent attorneys contribute the technical expertise.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Must an SEP holder grant a licence to everyone?

It must offer willing licensees a licence on FRAND terms. An unwilling user cannot rely on the FRAND defence.

Can the UPC set a global royalty?

This has not yet been conclusively resolved. So far the UPC has focused on whether the parties have fulfilled their obligations under Huawei/ZTE.

What are typical FRAND rates?

That depends on the standard, the portfolio and the product. We work with comparable licences and economic expert opinions.

Read more

Related topics

Act now

Deadlines are running – we review your case at short notice

Statement of defence, appeal, protective letter or opt-out: many steps before the Unified Patent Court are subject to strict deadlines. Tell us about your case – confidentially and under attorney-client privilege.

horak Attorneys-at-law · Patent Attorneys
Head office Hanover: 0511 35 73 56-0
info@upc-anwalt.de
10 offices in Germany · advice also by video call

As of November 2026. This information is provided for general guidance only and does not replace legal advice in an individual case. Legal bases: Agreement on a Unified Patent Court (UPCA), Rules of Procedure of the UPC (RoP), Regulations (EU) No 1257/2012 and 1260/2012, German Patent Act, German Utility Model Act, EPC, PCT.

Scroll to top