Security for legal costs: SMEs have to pay too

Several Court of Appeal decisions from 2026 sharpen the rules on security for legal costs. For small companies, special-purpose vehicles and funded claimants, the calculation changes.

SME status is no free pass

In La Siddhi/Athena (UPC_CoA_48/2026), the Court of Appeal confirmed security of €75,000 against a revocation claimant before the Central Division in Milan. Unlike court fees, R. 158 RoP provides no relief for small and medium-sized enterprises. SME status may be taken into account in determining the amount; here the security was around 60% of the maximum recoverable amount of €112,000.

Insurance instead of a bank guarantee

In Syntorr/Arthrex (UPC_CoA_889/2025), the Court of Appeal set aside security of €2 million. The claimant had taken out litigation insurance with an insurer authorised in the EU, protected against early termination. There were therefore no longer any legitimate doubts about cost reimbursement.

Special-purpose vehicles in focus

In Nixu/Infoblox the Hamburg Local Division ordered security of €200,000. The decisive factor was not the defendant’s US domicile, but that the claimant was a newly formed company whose patents and income were pledged to its litigation funder.

And on appeal?

According to Suinno/Microsoft (UPC_CoA_21/2026), only the respondent can request security in appeal proceedings. Microsoft obtained €600,000.

An overview of the requirements and maximum amounts can be found on our page Security for costs.

Case examples

01

Start-up as claimant

A start-up wants to enforce a patent. We factor in possible security from the outset and examine litigation insurance.

02

Defendant against a patent assertion entity

A client is sued by an assertion entity. With the statement of defence we apply for security and show the lack of assets.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

How high can the security be?

It is based on the recoverable costs, which are capped between €38,000 and €2 million depending on the value in dispute.

Questions about your case? Our UPC team (Horak, Ziegeler, Karfusehr, Mai, Umberg, Gitmann-Kopilevich, Behrend, Friedlein) represents you before all divisions of the Unified Patent Court. Describe your case, contact form or call us: 0511 35 73 56-0.

This article reflects the legal position on its date of publication and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.

Security for legal costs: SMEs have to pay too
Scroll to top