UPC proceedings · Defence

Sued before the Unified Patent Court

A UPC action triggers strict deadlines: one month for objections to jurisdiction and language, three months for the full statement of defence including the counterclaim for revocation. Act immediately.

  • Representation before all UPC divisions
  • Attorneys-at-law and patent attorneys
  • Reply usually within 24 hours
1 monthPreliminary objection
3 monthsStatement of defence
with the defenceCounterclaim
only exceptionallyExtension

The first steps after service

The action is served via the electronic case management system (CMS) or by post. Note the date of service – all further deadlines depend on it. Please forward the action with all exhibits to us immediately. We will check straight away:

  • whether the division has jurisdiction and the language of proceedings is correct,
  • whether the patent had been opted out or proceedings before a national court take precedence,
  • which claims are asserted and which products are affected,
  • which prior art speaks against the patent (search),
  • whether security for costs should be requested (R. 158 RoP),
  • which settlement or licensing options exist.

Preliminary objection within one month

With the preliminary objection (R. 19 RoP) you challenge the jurisdiction of the court, the competence of the division or the language of the statement of claim. The deadline is one month from service. If it is missed, the objection is generally precluded. Typical arguments: the defendant has neither its seat nor any infringing acts in the area of the chosen division; a valid opt-out was disregarded; earlier national proceedings between the same parties are pending.

Statement of defence within three months

The statement of defence (R. 23, 24 RoP) must be filed within three months from service. It must contain the entire defence: denial of infringement, counter-arguments on claim construction, technical expert opinions, rights of prior use, exhaustion, licensing defences and offers of evidence. The counterclaim for revocation is usually filed together with the statement of defence (R. 25 RoP). Three months sound long, but are barely enough for searches, expert opinions and translations unless work starts at once.

Lines of defence at a glance

DefenceWhat it is about
No infringementThe product does not realise all features of the claim, not even by equivalence
InvalidityLack of novelty or inventive step, added matter, insufficiency of disclosure
Right of prior useOwn use before the priority date – under the national law of the state concerned (Art. 28 UPCA)
ExhaustionGoods were placed on the market in the EEA by the proprietor or with its consent (Art. 29 UPCA)
ExceptionsExperimental use, Bolar exemption, private use (Art. 27 UPCA)
Licence / FRANDExisting licence or willingness-to-license defence for standard essential patents
ProportionalityThe court may order measures at its discretion, weighing the interests involved

Strategic options alongside the defence

In parallel with the defence, we check whether an opposition at the EPO (within nine months of grant) is still possible, whether a design-around can be implemented at short notice and whether your position can be strengthened by your own patents. For standard essential patents we prepare a FRAND offer. Early mediation through the PMAC can also reduce costs and uncertainty.

Security and costs

If the claimant is domiciled outside the EU or there are doubts about its solvency, the defendant may request security for costs (R. 158 RoP). The defendant’s cost risk is limited by the reimbursement ceilings; at the same time, if successful, it can claim reimbursement of its own costs up to that ceiling.

Deadlines before the UPC are rarely extended. Anyone who misses the statement of defence risks a decision by default (R. 355 RoP). Please send us the action on the day of service.

From our practice

Case examples

Typical situations we encounter in our advisory work – anonymised and simplified.

01

A jurisdiction objection succeeds

A Polish company is sued before a local division although it has neither its seat nor any sales in that state. We file the preliminary objection within one month. The division declares that it lacks competence; the claimant has to sue again before another division and loses valuable time.

02

Right of prior use in Germany

A manufacturer of conveyor belts has used a tensioning device for years. Using design drawings and invoices, we prove that it used the invention in Germany before the priority date. For Germany the right of prior use under Section 12 of the German Patent Act applies; for the other states we negotiate a licence.

03

A counterclaim based on a search in China

Against a patent on LED driver circuits, we find a Chinese utility model that discloses all features. We have it translated with certification and file the counterclaim for revocation with the statement of defence. The patent is revoked for all UPC states.

04

Security for costs against a patent assertion entity

A patent assertion entity with no apparent assets in the EU sues an online retailer. We apply for security for costs. The court orders security in the six-figure range; the claimant withdraws the action shortly afterwards.

05

A design-around during the proceedings

A manufacturer of fully automatic coffee machines is sued over a brewing unit. In parallel with the defence, we work with its engineers on a design that does not realise one claim feature. A freedom-to-operate opinion confirms the design-around, limiting the risk to existing stock.

06

Bolar exemption for clinical trials

A biotech company is sued over trials with a patented active ingredient. We rely on the exemption for studies and trials required for marketing authorisation (Art. 27(d) UPCA). The court dismisses the request for an injunction regarding the trial activities.

Your attorneys

Your UPC team: authorised to represent before the Unified Patent Court

Michael Horak, Julia Ziegeler, Stefan Karfusehr, Robin Jannis Mai, Anna Umberg, Katharina Gitmann-Kopilevich, Karoline Behrend and Andreas Friedlein are attorneys-at-law admitted in Germany and are therefore entitled under Art. 48(1) UPCA to represent clients before all divisions of the Unified Patent Court and before the Court of Appeal in Luxembourg. Our patent attorneys contribute the technical expertise.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Can the deadline for the statement of defence be extended?

Only in exceptional cases and upon a reasoned request. Plan with the regular three months – and start the search and expert opinions immediately.

Do I have to file a counterclaim for revocation?

No, but it is usually the strongest lever. Alternatively, a stand-alone revocation action before the central division or an EPO opposition may be considered; this has tactical pros and cons that we discuss with you.

What happens if I do not respond?

At the claimant’s request, the court may issue a decision by default (R. 355 RoP). An application to set it aside is only possible within one month.

We are based outside the EU. Are we affected?

Yes, if your products are sold in UPC states. The judgment can be enforced against your distribution partners in the EU and block supply chains.

Read more

Related topics

Act now

Deadlines are running – we review your case at short notice

Statement of defence, appeal, protective letter or opt-out: many steps before the Unified Patent Court are subject to strict deadlines. Tell us about your case – confidentially and under attorney-client privilege.

horak Attorneys-at-law · Patent Attorneys
Head office Hanover: 0511 35 73 56-0
info@upc-anwalt.de
10 offices in Germany · advice also by video call

As of November 2026. This information is provided for general guidance only and does not replace legal advice in an individual case. Legal bases: Agreement on a Unified Patent Court (UPCA), Rules of Procedure of the UPC (RoP), Regulations (EU) No 1257/2012 and 1260/2012, German Patent Act, German Utility Model Act, EPC, PCT.

Scroll to top