With the start of the UPC, the prohibition of double protection in Germany fell away. A German patent can since exist alongside a European or unitary patent for the same invention.
The legal position
Previously, a German patent lost its effect to the extent that a European patent for the same invention took effect in Germany. Since 1 June 2023 this prohibition no longer applies. Both rights can coexist and be enforced independently of each other.
Why this is valuable
- Reinsurance: if the unitary patent is revoked by the UPC, the German patent remains – it must be attacked separately before the Federal Patent Court.
- Choice of forum: the German patent is enforced before the regional courts, the unitary patent before the UPC.
- Different claims: both patents can be tailored differently and thus cover different forms of infringement.
In practice
The first German filing lends itself as a priority application anyway. Instead of letting it lapse after the European subsequent filing, it can be pursued further.
Case examples
Two rights, two forums
A manufacturer of hydraulic systems uses the unitary patent before the UPC and, in parallel, the German patent before the Düsseldorf Regional Court.
Rescue after revocation
After revocation of the unitary patent, a German patent with a narrower claim remains and continues to be infringed – the client sues successfully in Germany.
Frequently asked questions
Is it always worth pursuing the German patent?
Not always. The costs of examination and renewal fees must be weighed against the additional protection.
Questions about your case? Our UPC team (Horak, Ziegeler, Karfusehr, Mai, Umberg, Gitmann-Kopilevich, Behrend, Friedlein) represents you before all divisions of the Unified Patent Court. Describe your case, contact form or call us: 0511 35 73 56-0.
This article reflects the legal position on its date of publication and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.
