Three years after the start, the Court of Appeal has developed its own, but compatible, standard for assessing inventive step.
The standard
The Court of Appeal first determines a realistic starting point in the prior art that the skilled person would have considered. It identifies the objective technical problem and asks whether the skilled person would have arrived at the claimed solution from there. Several starting points can be considered side by side – unlike the EPO’s strict problem-solution approach, which usually starts from the closest prior art.
Mixed inventions
For inventions with technical and non-technical features – such as software, AI or business methods – the court is guided by the COMVIK approach: only features that contribute to solving a technical problem can establish inventive step.
Consequences
For patent proprietors this means: the technical effect must be made clear in the patent specification. For challengers: put forward several starting points and prove the skilled person’s motivation.
Case examples
AI patent defended
For a patent on AI-supported defect detection, we bring out the measurable technical effect on the production plant. The patent is maintained.
Second starting point
In a revocation counterclaim, we put forward, in addition to the closest prior art, a second realistic starting point from which the solution is obvious.
Frequently asked questions
Is the UPC standard stricter than the EPO’s?
Not across the board. The results often coincide; the lines of reasoning differ.
Questions about your case? Our UPC team (Horak, Ziegeler, Karfusehr, Mai, Umberg, Gitmann-Kopilevich, Behrend, Friedlein) represents you before all divisions of the Unified Patent Court. Describe your case, contact form or call us: 0511 35 73 56-0.
This article reflects the legal position on its date of publication and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.
