Court of Appeal on patent amendments: juicer patent remains invalid

In early November 2026 the Court of Appeal confirmed the invalidity of a patent for a juicer – and gave important guidance on patent amendments.

The decision

The Court of Appeal confirmed that the manufacturer Hurom’s patent is invalid for lack of inventive step. At the same time, it commented on the admissibility requirements for applications to amend the patent and on the role played by the unamended description in interpreting amended claims.

Significance for patent proprietors

Auxiliary requests must be filed in time, completely and with reasons. Anyone amending claims should bear in mind that the description continues to be used for interpretation and is not automatically adjusted. Contradictions between amended claims and the original description can affect interpretation.

Practical recommendation

Auxiliary requests should be staggered from the outset and drafted with the description in mind. Where necessary, an amendment of the description should be requested.

Case examples

01

Staggered auxiliary requests

In a reply we file four auxiliary requests, each with an explanation of how the description supports the amended claims.

02

Interpretation used

Acting for the defendant, we argue that a passage of the unamended description makes the amended claim appear narrower than the proprietor contends.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Can I still amend claims on appeal?

Only to a limited extent. New auxiliary requests are generally admitted on appeal only if they could not have been filed earlier.

Questions about your case? Our UPC team (Horak, Ziegeler, Karfusehr, Mai, Umberg, Gitmann-Kopilevich, Behrend, Friedlein) represents you before all divisions of the Unified Patent Court. Describe your case, contact form or call us: 0511 35 73 56-0.

This article reflects the legal position on its date of publication and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.

Court of Appeal on patent amendments: juicer patent remains invalid
Scroll to top