CJEU BSH/Electrolux: foreign patent infringements before domestic courts

With its judgment of 25 February 2025 (C-339/22), the Grand Chamber of the CJEU changed the rules of the game for cross-border patent disputes in Europe.

What the case was about

BSH Hausgeräte sued Electrolux in Sweden for infringement of a European patent in several states, including Turkey. Electrolux objected that, because of the invalidity defence, the Swedish courts could not rule on foreign parts of the patent.

The key findings

  • A court at the defendant’s domicile in an EU state remains competent under Art. 4 of the Brussels Ia Regulation for the infringement of foreign patents, even if the defendant raises invalidity.
  • For patents from EU or Lugano states, validity with effect against everyone continues to be decided exclusively by the state of grant; the infringement court may stay its proceedings.
  • For patents from third countries (such as Turkey), the court may examine validity incidentally with effect between the parties.

Significance for the UPC

The UPC applies the Brussels Ia Regulation and is treated as a court common to the Contracting States for jurisdictional purposes. It can therefore, under certain circumstances, also rule on infringements in non-UPC states such as Spain, the United Kingdom or Switzerland if the defendant is domiciled in a UPC state. The local divisions have already made use of this possibility; the Court of Appeal has since defined the limits more precisely.

Case examples

01

Bundling proceedings

A German defendant sells in Germany, Austria and Spain. We examine whether a single action before the UPC can also cover the Spanish part of the European patent.

02

Defending against a long-arm action

A client is also sued for infringement in the United Kingdom. We examine whether the UK acts can be attributed to it at all – a point on which such actions frequently fail.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Does the judgment also apply to national courts?

Yes. German regional courts can also rule on foreign patent infringements according to these principles.

Questions about your case? Our UPC team (Horak, Ziegeler, Karfusehr, Mai, Umberg, Gitmann-Kopilevich, Behrend, Friedlein) represents you before all divisions of the Unified Patent Court. Describe your case, contact form or call us: 0511 35 73 56-0.

This article reflects the legal position on its date of publication and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.

CJEU BSH/Electrolux: foreign patent infringements before domestic courts
Scroll to top