Court of Appeal on patent amendments: juicer patent remains invalid

In early November 2026 the Court of Appeal confirmed the invalidity of a patent for a juicer – and gave important guidance on patent amendments. The decision The Court of Appeal confirmed that the manufacturer Hurom’s patent is invalid for lack of inventive step. At the same time, it commented on the admissibility requirements for […]

Central Division instead of local division: actions against defendants outside the UPC

Anyone suing a group with companies inside and outside the UPC states can choose the Central Division. The Court of Appeal so held in June 2026. The case Valeo had sued several Bosch companies before the Central Division in Paris, including a company domiciled outside the Contracting Member States. The Central Division referred the entire […]

Urgency in provisional proceedings: whoever waits too long loses

An application for provisional measures before the UPC can fail solely for lack of urgency – even if the patent is infringed. This is shown by a 2026 decision of the Court of Appeal. The case Guardant Health had applied to the Paris Local Division for provisional measures against Sophia Genetics. The division refused, and […]

Inventive step before the UPC: what the case law shows

Three years after the start, the Court of Appeal has developed its own, but compatible, standard for assessing inventive step. The standard The Court of Appeal first determines a realistic starting point in the prior art that the skilled person would have considered. It identifies the objective technical problem and asks whether the skilled person […]

Limits of long-arm jurisdiction: Court of Appeal sets aside Mannheim judgment

On 2 June 2026 the Court of Appeal set aside a much-noted judgment of the Mannheim Local Division that had found patent infringement also for the United Kingdom. The case In proceedings against Kodak, the Mannheim Local Division had found infringement both in Germany and in the United Kingdom. The Court of Appeal set these […]

Mannheim stops Chinese interim licence application: Nokia v Geely

After InterDigital/Amazon, the Mannheim Local Division has for the second time issued an order against a foreign interim licence – this time against proceedings in China. The case Nokia is enforcing standard-essential patents against the car manufacturer Geely. Geely applied in China for a worldwide interim licence to be determined. In spring 2026 the Mannheim […]

No unitary effect without Malta: Court of Appeal decides (UPC_CoA_8/2026)

On 9 February 2026 the UPC Court of Appeal answered an important question on the unitary patent – with consequences for all divisional applications from older parent applications. The case A patent from a divisional application was based on a parent application filed before Malta acceded to the EPC in 2007. Malta could therefore not […]

Scroll to top